Creating a Quick Test to Tell Apart Different Honey Types

Jim Crocker
20th April, 2024

Creating a Quick Test to Tell Apart Different Honey Types

Image Source: Natural Science News, 2024

Key Findings

  • McGill University researchers developed a faster method to verify honey's origins
  • The new 'dilute-and-shoot' technique accurately identifies honey types by their unique chemical fingerprints
  • This method simplifies detecting honey adulteration, ensuring consumers get genuine products
Honey, a sweet and natural product, has been cherished for centuries not only for its taste but also for its nutritional and health-promoting benefits. The value of honey is often linked to its botanical origin, with certain types fetching a premium price on the market. However, this has also made honey a prime target for fraudulent practices such as adulteration and mislabeling[2]. In response to this growing concern, researchers at McGill University have conducted a study[1] aimed at improving the methods used to verify the botanical origins of honey. The problem of honey fraud is not new. Previous research has highlighted the vulnerability of certain food ingredients, including honey, to economically motivated adulteration[3]. In the case of honey, adulteration can take many forms, such as the addition of sugar syrups or the misrepresentation of its geographical and botanical origins[2]. To combat these fraudulent activities, it is crucial to have reliable and efficient methods for honey authentication. Traditional methods for determining the authenticity of honey often involve complex and time-consuming procedures that focus on a limited number of known markers. These methods may not be sufficient to keep up with the sophisticated techniques employed by fraudsters. The recent study from McGill University addresses this challenge by introducing a 'dilute-and-shoot' approach that utilizes liquid chromatography (LC) coupled with quadrupole time-of-flight-mass spectrometry (QTOF-MS). This innovative approach aims to simplify and speed up the process of honey authentication by providing a non-targeted fingerprint of honeys from different floral sources. The research team tested various instrumental conditions, such as the type of column used in the LC, the composition of the mobile phase, the gradient of the chromatography, and the MS fragmentor voltage. These variables can significantly impact the quality of the data and the ability to classify honey according to its botanical origin. The study found that regardless of the conditions and the mathematical model applied—be it random forest, partial least squares-discriminant analysis, soft independent modelling by class analogy, or linear discriminant analysis—the data sets obtained were all capable of distinguishing between buckwheat, clover, and blueberry honeys. This finding is significant as it suggests that the 'dilute-and-shoot' LC-QTOF-MS method can be a quick and reliable way to record the chemical fingerprints of honey, which are unique to its botanical source. By identifying these fingerprints, it becomes possible to detect honey adulteration and ensure that consumers are getting the genuine product they are paying for. The approach developed by the McGill University team builds upon the existing body of knowledge on honey authentication[4]. While chromatographic methods have been the most frequently used for assessing honey's botanical origin, the 'dilute-and-shoot' technique represents a step forward in terms of simplicity and effectiveness. It also highlights the importance of using advanced analytical methods and chemometrics—a field that applies mathematical and statistical techniques to analyze chemical data—to uncover markers of authenticity[4]. The implications of this study are far-reaching. By providing a method that is both simple and effective, it paves the way for more widespread monitoring of honey authenticity. This could benefit not only consumers but also honest producers who are negatively affected by the fraudulent activities in the market. Furthermore, the research opens the door for the development of advanced predictive models that could further streamline the process of determining honey's botanical origins. In summary, the work by McGill University offers a promising new tool in the fight against honey fraud. By leveraging advanced analytical techniques, it is now possible to more accurately and efficiently ensure the authenticity of honey, protecting both consumers and producers in the process. The study serves as an example of how scientific innovation can address real-world issues and improve the integrity of our food supply.

BiotechBiochemPlant Science


Main Study

1) Development of a LC-QTOF-MS based dilute-and-shoot approach for the botanical discrimination of honeys.

Published 22nd May, 2024 (future Journal edition)

Related Studies

2) A Comprehensive Review on the Main Honey Authentication Issues: Production and Origin.

3) Development and application of a database of food ingredient fraud and economically motivated adulteration from 1980 to 2010.

4) Honey authenticity: analytical techniques, state of the art and challenges.

Related Articles

An unhandled error has occurred. Reload 🗙