Diverse Traits in Tiny Fish Groups Living in Lava Landscapes

Greg Howard
16th April, 2024

Diverse Traits in Tiny Fish Groups Living in Lava Landscapes

Image Source: Natural Science News, 2024

Key Findings

  • Study in Iceland shows small Arctic charr populations adapt in isolated lava caves
  • Despite limited gene flow, these fish exhibit diverse physical traits, suggesting adaptive evolution
  • Environmental factors like cave temperature and size only partly explain the fish's physical variations
Understanding the forces that shape the diversity of life forms is a central pursuit in evolutionary biology. A recent study by researchers from Hólar University[1] has made significant strides in this field by investigating how small, isolated populations of Arctic charr, a species of freshwater fish, adapt and evolve in unique environments. This study is particularly important because it sheds light on the evolutionary processes occurring in small fragmented populations, which are often overlooked in favor of larger, more connected populations or those along environmental gradients. The study focused on 24 separate populations of Arctic charr found in groundwater-filled lava caves within a relatively small geographic area. Interestingly, these populations are isolated from one another, with no visible water connections between them, which makes them an excellent model for studying evolutionary mechanisms in small, fragmented groups. One of the key challenges in such research is distinguishing between phenotypic changes that are genetically based and those that result from phenotypic plasticity—the ability of an organism to change its phenotype in response to environmental conditions[2]. Additionally, it's crucial to determine whether these changes are adaptive, meaning they increase the chances of survival and reproduction in the given environment, or if they are neutral, not providing any particular advantage or disadvantage. The Hólar University study tackled these challenges by comparing patterns of phenotypic divergence, which refers to differences in physical traits, with patterns of neutral genetic divergence, which are genetic differences that do not necessarily affect the fitness of the fish. By contrasting these patterns and relating them to environmental factors, the researchers were able to model how much of the phenotypic variation could be explained by the environment, while considering the genetic structure of the populations. This approach is crucial because it allows scientists to parse out the effects of gene flow and genetic drift—two factors that can influence population structure. Previous studies have pointed out that many natural populations are not at equilibrium, as assumed by traditional models, and that the influences of gene flow and drift are often conflated, making it difficult to assess their individual contributions to population divergence[3]. The current study circumvents these issues by directly relating genetic and phenotypic divergence to specific environmental factors. The findings of the Hólar University researchers build upon earlier work that has shown how geographic barriers, such as rising sea levels, can lead to genetic drift and differentiation in populations with limited dispersal abilities[4]. The Arctic charr populations in the lava caves likely experienced similar historical bottlenecks and genetic drift, yet the study's results suggest that adaptive phenotypic variation is still possible in these small, isolated groups. Moreover, the study also contributes to our understanding of how phenotypic plasticity can influence speciation and adaptation. Previous research has demonstrated that plasticity can evolve in populations exposed to different environments and can either hinder or facilitate the formation of reproductive barriers[5]. The Arctic charr populations offer a real-world example of how plasticity might play a role in adapting to unique ecological niches, even within a fragmented landscape. In summary, the study by Hólar University provides valuable insights into how small, isolated populations can undergo adaptive evolution despite historical constraints such as bottlenecks and genetic drift. By carefully analyzing the interplay between phenotypic and genetic variation and environmental factors, the researchers have contributed to a more nuanced understanding of evolutionary processes. Their work underscores the complexity of natural selection and adaptation and highlights the importance of considering a broad range of populations and environments when studying the dynamics of evolution.



Main Study

1) Fine scale diversity in the lava: genetic and phenotypic diversity in small populations of Arctic charr Salvelinus alpinus

Published 15th April, 2024


Related Studies

2) Climate change, adaptation, and phenotypic plasticity: the problem and the evidence.




4) Historical fragmentation of islands and genetic drift in populations of Galápagos lava lizards (Microlophus albemarlensis complex).


5) The consequences of phenotypic plasticity for ecological speciation.


Related Articles

An unhandled error has occurred. Reload 🗙