How Whaling and Krill Fishing Impact Whale-Krill Relationships

Jim Crocker
7th March, 2024

How Whaling and Krill Fishing Impact Whale-Krill Relationships

Image Source: Natural Science News, 2024

Key Findings

  • In the Antarctic, despite fewer whales, krill numbers have unexpectedly declined, not increased
  • A new model shows complex interactions can cause krill populations to fluctuate unpredictably
  • The study suggests environmental factors and food web dynamics may explain the "krill paradox."
In the cold waters of the Antarctic, a mystery has puzzled scientists for years: despite a drastic reduction in whale populations due to historic whaling activities, their main food source, the Antarctic krill, has not surged in numbers as expected. This counterintuitive scenario, known as the "krill paradox," has raised questions about the intricate dynamics within marine ecosystems. A recent study from Central China Normal University[1] offers fresh insights into this phenomenon, challenging our understanding of predator-prey relationships and the broader implications for ecosystem management. The Antarctic ecosystem has undergone significant changes over the past century. With the reduction of whale populations, it was anticipated that krill numbers would rise due to the decrease in predation pressure. However, observations have shown a decline in krill abundance, a situation that contradicts simple ecological models where fewer predators should mean more prey. This unexpected turn of events has led researchers to delve deeper into the complex interactions between these species. To explore the relationship between krill and their whale predators, the study revisited a mathematical model known as the harvested predator-prey model with a Holling I functional response. This model describes how predators consume prey and incorporates the effects of human activities, like fishing, on the dynamics of the system. The researchers aimed to understand the conditions under which the model could explain the observed decline in krill populations despite the reduced number of whales. The study's findings are based on a sophisticated analysis of the model's equilibrium points—conditions where the populations of krill and whales remain constant over time. Researchers identified that the model can have up to two positive equilibria, which are essentially stable states of the ecosystem. They discovered that depending on the location of these equilibria, the model could exhibit different behaviors, including what is known as a Bogdanov-Takens bifurcation and a Hopf bifurcation. These are types of mathematical phenomena that indicate sudden shifts in the stability of the system, leading to new, potentially unexpected behaviors. For instance, when two positive equilibria exist within a certain parameter range, the system can undergo complex changes in stability, which could explain the fluctuations in krill populations. The model also revealed that under specific conditions, there could be three distinct cycles where krill and whale populations rise and fall in a predictable pattern. Remarkably, one of these cycles crosses a critical threshold, beyond which the dynamics of the system could change dramatically, potentially shedding light on the krill paradox. The study's simulations suggest that the interaction between krill and whales is more nuanced than previously thought. The decline in krill could be due to a combination of factors, including environmental changes and the complex feedback mechanisms within the food web. These findings build upon earlier research[2] that suggested baleen whales play a significant role in their ecosystems, not only through predation but also by recycling nutrients like iron, which can enhance marine productivity. Moreover, the study underscores the importance of ecosystem-based management in fisheries, as highlighted in previous work[3]. It emphasizes the need for models that can account for the multifaceted interactions within marine ecosystems, particularly when managing species like krill that are both harvested by humans and a crucial part of the diet for many marine animals. In conclusion, the research from Central China Normal University provides a mathematical framework that can help explain the perplexing decline in krill populations in the Antarctic. It illustrates the complexity of marine ecosystems and the importance of considering the full range of interactions among species, environmental factors, and human activities. As our understanding of these dynamics improves, so too will our ability to manage and preserve the delicate balance of life in our oceans.

EnvironmentEcologyMarine Biology


Main Study

1) Effects of whaling and krill fishing on the whale-krill predation dynamics: bifurcations in a harvested predator-prey model with Holling type I functional response.

Published 6th March, 2024

Related Studies

2) Baleen whale prey consumption based on high-resolution foraging measurements.

3) Modelling Southern Ocean ecosystems: krill, the food-web, and the impacts of harvesting.

Journal: Biological reviews of the Cambridge Philosophical Society, Issue: Vol 81, Issue 4, Nov 2006

Related Articles

An unhandled error has occurred. Reload đź—™